Ask any comics fan what their biggest concerns about the future are, and
you'll probably get a list that looks something like this:
- Moving out of my parents' basement
- Kissing a girl
- The next Batman movie
And not necessarily in that order.
Movies about Batman get worse over time. The first one still kicks a pretty
large chunk of ass; the second one is an underappreciated cult masterpiece;
the third and fourth films blow. Some fans attempt to rationalize the third
one; "sure, it's different," they'll say, "more of a sixties' pop camp
version of the Caped Crusader, but it's pretty cool."
Wrongo, folks. It blows. So does Batman and Robin.
Here's how bad I thought Batman and Robin was. I saw it on opening
night in a packed theater on a beautiful June evening, and I FELL ASLEEP.
Back in 199something, I attended the midnight premiere of Dick Tracy
where you had to buy a T-shirt as your "ticket" to get in, and I stayed
awake while my dad snored away next to me. I NEVER fall asleep in movie
theaters. But I slept happily through part of Batman and Robin, and
even missed Coolio's cameo. Sucks to be me, or perhaps it doesn't, since I
didn't have to sit through fifteen minutes of that shitfest.)
The weird thing is that Batman movies don't have to suck donkey balls.
There is now over sixty years of fantastic source material to draw upon.
Granted, some of that sucks donkey balls too, but some of it doesn't, and
some of it is seminal pop fiction. Even if you picked a random issue of
1940s Batman and adapted it, it would probably be better than
anything that a professional screenwriter in the 1990s has come up with.
Even one of those wacky sci-fi Batman stories from the fifties where the
Dark Knight is turned into a slimy alien would be better than the current
directionless mess of the Batman film series.
Warner Bros.' failure to produce meaningful, powerful, epic Batman
films is pathetic. It's uncalled for. So in case you're reading, WB execs,
here's a few handy tips on what to do with the next Batman movie:
1) Return to the source material. This character hasn't survived
sixty years of continuous publishing for no reason whatsoever. There has to
be some secret to his success. Read old Batman comics, take copious
notes, and bring what is on the page to the screen. Bob Kane, creator of
Batman, personally consulted on the first Batman film, and I think
his participation shows, because the movie retains the look and feel of
classic Batman. That's what we want: classic Batman, not reworked crap that
barely resembles the character.
2) Adapt. If you can't invent your own decent Batman story based on
reading and re-reading the greatest Batman comics of the past half-century,
then just steal the plot of one and use it. DC owns those stories, fer
chrissake, and Warner Bros. owns DC. They belong to you. Take Frank Miller's
Dark Knight Returns or Year One, or Jim Starlin's "A Death in
the Family," or anything that faithfully delivers a great Batman story.
Swipe the plot, make a movie, madly count the money as it pours into your
coffers.
3) Try variety. The Batman film series should be like the
James Bond series. Every film is similar, every film is somehow slightly
connected, yet they work as independent entertainments built around a
classic central character. As an ongoing series of films rather than a set
of rapidly-declining sequels, there's much more room for experimentation and
variety.
You don't have to pour $150 million down an entertainment black hole and
construct some horrific, bloated "blockbuster" to make a Batman
movie. Give a young edgy filmmaker $20 million and points off the back end,
and make them write a small, intense Batman film. Many of the best
Batman comics stories have been built around the Dark Knight
Detective tracking the scum of Gotham City with only his wits and his
all-too-human strength--minus the Bat-boats, wacky supervillains and
convoluted action sequences. Go the small route instead of the overblown
one. A lean, mean Batman movie would return to the character's roots
and deliver with intensity while saving you tons of cash.
Then do a big-budget Batman supervillain battle, and then pit the
Dark Knight against the Gotham City mob in an Untouchables-esque
story, then send him off to fight Ra's Al Ghul in a James Bond-esque
adventure, then drop him in the jungles of Africa to hunt down an escaped
serial killler...
The possibilities are endless. Explore them.
4) Get some new talent. Some of the best ideas I've yet heard
regarding the live-action Batman film franchise have involved two
names: Ben Affleck and Paul Dini. Affleck would make the perfect young
Batman, attractive yet detached and brooding, passionate yet obsessed with
his mission. Dini, who has served as the creative mastermind behind the
exceptional animated Batman series of the past several years, was
rumored to have been writing a live-action Batman script as well, but
that script never made it to production.
These are two talents who would be tremendously well-suited to
participating in the Batman film franchise. Why are they only rumors
and not reality? If you insist on going cheap, hire ten young screenwriters
with potential, pay them each $50,000 and demand a Batman movie script from
each. See what happens. It's clear that people like Joel Schumacher and
Akiva Goldsman will only succeed in driving the franchise further into the
ground if they return to work on future Batman films. We need new
blood. Batman needs new blood. The old blood is clotted and nasty.
5) Understand the character. Whatever you do, you MUST do this,
because you've sucked at it for two Batman movies so far. Perhaps you
suits are a bit too brain-dead to figure out exactly where Bruce Wayne is
coming from, so let me try to break it down for you: he's Zorro with an
Oedipal complex. He does not have to be psychotic; he does not have to be a
closet vinyl fetishist. He just has to be a dark man with a crushed soul who
is driven to hunt crime. How hard can that be? Again, I must say--it's
worked for sixty years, why tamper with the formula with some whacked-out
crap that comes from left field? The character doesn't need to be
reinvented; he needs to be understood and interpreted properly. If you do
nothing else, PLEASE try to do this, because to fail in understanding Batman
is to insult one of the great fictional creations of our century. He's an
icon. Try to figure out why.
6) Worst case scenario: make me the star. Cast Michelle Pfeiffer as
Catwoman again. Let us have sex on camera. I guarantee big box office.