It's about time.
That's the overriding emotion I had upon hearing about John Linnell's new
State Songs release. His band They Might Be Giants have been pretty
busy for the past few years, but that still hasn't stopped co-Giant John
Flansburgh from releasing solo material with side project Mono Puff. It's
always been fascinating to consider what would happen if Linnell unleashed
his considerable solo talent upon an unsuspecting recording studio, and
State Songs is the result of such an onslaught.
The verdict? Stuffed to bursting with infectious pop hooks like a musical
Thanksgiving turkey, State Songs is everything you love about
TMBG--the radical stylistic shifts, the abstract yet hilarious lyrics, the
effortless musicality--all brought together on one album. It's as good as a
great Giants album, and yet thanks to Linnell's distinct voice as a
songwriter, it also stands as a unique achievement outside of the Giants
catalog.
In listening to Songs, longtime Giants fans will inevitably consider
just what it is about Linnell's songwriting that contrasts his work with
that of Flansburgh. To unfairly generalize, Flansie's writing often takes a
skewed view of our reality and relationships--look no further than his
classic "Narrow Your Eyes" from Apollo 18 to see one of his greatest
compositions on a failed love affair.
Linnell's lyrical worldview is similarly skewed, but can also seem borne of
a reality that none of us may ever understand. For the songs on State
Songs, one might expect that he'd take wacky facts about each state and
set them to music, as he similarly did on "James K. Polk" from the
Factory Showroom album. Instead, he's used each state's name as
inspiration for some unrelated and often bizzare meditations.
"Montana" tells the tale of a man on his death bed whose final words
consist entirely of the poignant observation that "Montana is a leg." The
tale of "Arkansas" is actually the tale of an enormous seafaring vessel
constructed in the shape of the state itself. Naturally, the vessel
sinks--shades of Titanic? In the chorus to "Utah," Linnell defiantly
proclaims, "I forget you/I forget you/I forget Utah." "Pennsylvania" earns
only a series of "La-la-la-la" lyrics from Linnell, and unbeknownst to its
innocent citizenry, there is another West Virginia lurking within West
Virginia.
It's all classic absurd comedy from Linnell's pen, often conjuring
unexpected pathos when combined with his melodies. There's a sincere sadness
in imagining the lone woman waving her handkerchief as the good ship
Arkansas sinks slowly into the sea--and yet, that sadness is soon undercut
by Linnell singing in a low register and performing lines as the ship
itself. When it's not melancholy, as Linnell's melodies can often be, the
music is all catchy pop brilliance, from the uptempo guitar pop of "Songs of
the Fifty States" to the percussive piano-driven "South Carolina."
There's also a lot of fun to be had in the near-instrumentals on State
Songs, such as the aforementioned "Pennsylvania" and the rave-up
"Michigan," a loud, fast and out of control tune reminiscent of "The Famous
Polka" that only features brief lyrics near its end. The opening track,
"Illinois," is performed entirely on a vintage band organ, which required
Linnell to recruit a technician to punch his melodies into a roll of paper
and then run the roll featuring his song through a massive band organ. One
organ on the album was found in an afficianado's home in Long Island,
another inside the carousel in Central Park. Four songs feature band organ
along with Linnell's vocals and instrumental additions, but it's this first
song that spotlights the organ most effectively and sets the perfect playful
tone for the rest of the album.
John Linnell has finally graced TMBG fans with a solo project, and it's a
doozy. State Songs is just about as much fun as you can have
listening to a CD, and hopefully dancing and singing along with wild
abandon. It's a far cry from a travelogue on sixteen of America's finest
states, but then again, what fun would that be?