It's sad to watch a once-great artist decay, especially when they've always
displayed such a fire for their art. Given the choice, I'm all for burning
out rather than fading away--the fade-out can get so ugly that it's painful
to watch.
Case in point: one Kevin Rowland. There's no reason why the name should
ring any bells, but if you don't recognize his crowning achievement in the
annals of pop music, then you've spent too much time inside that cave where
you live. He's the songwriter and lead singer on "Come On Eileen," the early
eighties' dance hit for Rowland's band, Dexy's Midnight Runners. Rowland
recorded a couple of classic "celtic soul" records with Dexy's in the early
eighties, but only "Come On Eileen" has really outlived the era. It's become
one of the most enduring singles from the decade.
It endures for good reason. It's bloody brilliant. You've probably danced
your pretty little brains out to it countless times without ever realizing
just how amazing it is. It's an anthem for youth, a defiant blast of pure
pop genius against the stagnation of daily life, and one of the great
statutory love songs of all time.
If only any of the above could be said of Rowland's latest effort, My
Beauty. He's traded in Dexy's shrill horn section for saccharine
violins, his gutteral growl of rebellion for the flaccid wail of middle-age.
His fire has burned out, and the resulting pile of ashes makes for one
abysmal album.
There is exactly one song where Rowland manages to rekindle any sense of
his past glories, his remake of "Concrete and Clay." Driven by acoustic
guitar, it's a light and airy reading of the tune that floats easily into
your brain. Otherwise, My Beauty is a steaming mound of crap.
Try--just TRY--making your way through the album's opening song, a cover of
(you will NOT believe this) "The Greatest Love of All" by Whitney Houston.
Now, for what it is, "The Greatest Love of All" is not a bad song. As
eighties power ballads go, I'd put it right up there with "Total Eclipse of
the Heart" and "All By Myself." But you take away Whitney, and you're in
trouble. Drop in Kevin Rowland instead of Whitney, and you've got the aural
equivalent of a train wreck. The track nearly drowns in a sea of overwrought
string arrangements, with Rowland lazily crooning above it all. He sounds
kinda like Frank Sinatra, if Sinatra had sucked ass.
But wait--there's more. Some of the other tunes Rowland defiles on My
Beauty: "Rag Doll" by the Four Seasons, "The Long and Winding Road" by
the Beatles and "You'll Never Walk Alone" from the Rodgers and Hammerstein
musical Carousel. Each one awash in strings, each one stripped of any
redeeming value, each one seemingly more dreadful than the last. I would
love some insight on what inspired Rowland to choose these tunes--my bet is
that it probably has less to do with artistic intent and more to do with who
was willing to let him beat their song to a bloody pulp on compact disc.
Heck, when I first heard that Bruce Springsteen wouldn't let Rowland cover
"Thunder Road," I was sorta peeved at the Boss' presumptions. Now I thank
God that Rowland never got near it.
As if the mere idea of a formerly talented musician killing his stagnant
career right before your very ears weren't bad enough, Rowland pushes the
songs into absurdity with his constant need to "personalize" each one. Of
course, they're not his to rewrite, but why should that stop him? On the
Monkees' "Daydream Believer," the opening hook of the chorus transforms from
"Cheer up, Sleepy Jean" to "Cheer up, Little G." Who the fuck is little G?
Who the fuck cares? And all those untranslatable mumbles and howls that used
to sound so empassioned and revealing on Dexy's tunes? Now they're
self-indulgent whines.
This is one awful album. It's uninspired, it's lifeless and it's
sentimental enough to make even Kathie Lee Gifford wanna puke. I'm all for
taking Kevin Rowland out behind the shed and putting him out of his misery.
I'm not asking for him to go back in time and keep cranking out the same
Dexy's record for the rest of his life...actually, yeah, I am. Anything's
better than this dreck he tries to pass off as "music." To paraphrase Betty
Davis, whatta disaster.