The Bachelor is a horrifying tale about what the world would be like if
Chris O'Donnell were at the center of the universe. As you can imagine, it's
pretty sobering stuff. A seemingly intelligent woman like Renee Zellweger is
reduced to blithering idiocy, the talents of gifted actors like James
Cromwell, Hal Holbrook and Peter Ustinov are completely wasted, and every
fret and worry that crosses O'Donnell's prettified brow is agonized over as
though the fate of the world were in jeopardy.
That's largely because the world as known in The Bachelor IS in jeopardy,
since that world revolves blandly around its center, Chris O'Donnell
(portraying factory foreman Jimmy Shannon--really, the two seem virtually
interchangeable), and that center is in jeopardy because it has twenty-four
hours to marry someone and win a $100 million inheritence from its
grandfather (Ustinov). Otherwise, O'Donnell will get nothing, the billiards
manufacturing company that his grandfather owns will be sold off, and over
200 people that we don't care much about except as O'Donnell's grateful
servants will become jobless. Tragic.
Because O'Donnell is a selfish and shallow asshole, he doesn't have
enough good sense to just marry Zellweger (in the role of Ann--also
interchangeable with the actress, since the role is little more than a set of
O'Donnell-centric emotional outbursts strung together) and be done with it.
Ann is the girl Jimmy really loves, but unfortunately, O'Donnell gets wrapped
up in a belabored metaphor about bachelors being stallions who are free to
run around munching all the grass they want, and I'm sure you can guess what
the "grass" represents. He's trapped in this metaphor and unable to accept
his love for Zellweger. I'm afraid I can't blame him; if Zellweger is
really as boring and one-dimensional as her character in this film, I'd be
afraid to tie the knot as well.
So instead of marrying Ann (he thinks she's gone to Greece for good, but
she changed her mind and went home for the weekend instead--funny how those
things happen), Jimmy runs around for the better part of those 24 hours
approaching an endless parade of gorgeous women and asking them to marry him
for fifty million dollars. This accomplishes nothing for the audience; women
think these chicks onscreen are insane because their panties are all wadded
up for O'Donnell and they'd marry him in a second, and men think O'Donnell is
a son of a bitch because they're jealous that he's shagged Mariah Carey and
Brooke Shields in the same lifetime.
Both emotional responses--the envious bitterness of female viewers and
the jealous hatred of male viewers--come to a head in the film's climactic
sequence, as literally thousands of women take up residence in a church to
win a chance at scoring O'Donnell's hand in marriage. That's where those
images from the commercials come from, of all those brides chasing O'Donnell
around the streets of San Francisco. The plot twist makes for some amazing
visuals, but strains the incredulidity of the plot way past the breaking
point. C'mon, Chris; you're a very cute young actor who has at least twenty
more years of hotness ahead of you. Why does your movie need to work so hard
at reminding the audience just how yummy a catch you must be? Leave that shit
to Harrison Ford; he's the old fogey, not you.
Aside from its absurd and unabashedly O'Donnell-centric plot, The Bachelor
suffers from that most damaging of comedic ailments: it ain't funny. There's
no other way to put it. Most of the jokes hit the theater floor with echoing
thuds, and the ones that do work just sorta hang there, suspended in the
abyss of the film's unfunniness, until another unfunny one-liner spits out
and knocks it off the screen. The jokes aren't even presented in a way that
demonstrates any sense of comedic timing, so you can't trick yourself into
believing that they're funny just because they zing past your head in the
theater. Each scene drags like RuPaul, bad joke piles on top of bad joke, and
before long you're wishing you could marry O'Donnell's sorry ass just to end
the film and put the audience out of its misery.
You might be wondering what makes this manipulative, star-fucked romantic
comedy any different from the other manipulative, sstar-fucked romantic
comedies churned out of the Hollywood money machine on a regular basis. The
only distinguishing characteristic I can come up with that makes The Bachelor
more awful than any of its ilk is that its shamelessness is constantly
exposed. Whether it's the stale and unfunny dialogue, the dragging comic
timing, the vapidity of Zellweger or the sheer mindnumbing boredom inspired
by O'Donnell's performance, there's always something there to remind you that
yes, this is just another worthless romantic comedy and yes, you have
forty-five more minutes to sit through before you can go home and try to get
into your best girl's pants. It's everything that's awful about "chick
flicks" and bad movies all wrapped together, dripping constantly from
O'Donnell's shit-eating grin.
More than anything, The Bachelor proves that a universe built around
Chris O'Donnell is a terrifying place to be.