At one point in "As Good As It Gets," Melvin Udall (Jack Nicholson)
confronts a room full of people waiting to see a psychiatrist and
questions, "What if this is as good as it gets?" If this film is indeed as
good as cinema gets I can't say I'd mind too much. It is sometimes
raucously funny, sometimes quietly despairing, but always entertaining. I
didn't even look at my watch once during the two hours and eighteen minutes
of the movie, something that happens only rarely.
The great strength of this film lies in the writing of Mark Andrus and
James L. Brooks. The language is fresh, original, and (in the case of
Melvin) outright offensive. Melvin is a rarity in today's cinema: a
character who is not afraid to say exactly what is on his mind regardless
of when the thoughts pass through his head. A popular writer, Melvin is
also a diagnosed obsessive-compulsive, with all the patterns of behavior
that go along with it. He flips the locks on his doors at least five
times, and washes his hands with an unopened bar of soap every time he
touches something or something touches him outside the secluded world of
his apartment. He has no friends and makes no effort to relate to other
people, simply because it is not possible for him to do so.
Of course, this leads to situations that are amusing to watch from the
comfort of theater chairs, but are considerably less attractive to the
characters who are forced to share Melvin's world. He clashes with
everyone, from his gay neighbor Simon to a girl who works in his
publisher's office to an absolutely adorable dog. The only human being who
seems to have any effect on Melvin at all is Carol, a waitress at the one
restaurant to which he will go. She manages to at least partially control
him, and he does occasionally make an effort to modulate his behavior
around her.
The supporting characters are as well-drawn as Melvin, and the actors
play them extremely well. One of the great surprises of the movie was Greg
Kinnear's Simon, a gay artist who clashes frequently with his eccentric
neighbor. Kinnear did a nice job in other films such as "Sabrina" and
"Dear God," but this time he proves beyond a shadow of a doubt that he can
ACT. He creates a character that is very sympathetic and just as
interesting as Nicholson's Melvin, but in a completely different way.
Carol, played by Helen Hunt, comes across as a very old spirit in a young
body, which is understandably difficult for an actor to achieve but which
Hunt carries off beautifully and without visible effort.
The unlikely trio complement each other very well, and the mingling of
the separate paths of their lives is most convincing. They move from being
scarcely able to stand each other to genuine friendship, even after such
inauspicious beginnings as Melvin bluntly introducing them as, "Carol the
waitress" and "Simon the fag."
This film allows the viewer to travel along with the characters and to
appreciate the subtle changes that come over them. This is due to both the
great acting and the superb writing, making the trip a most enjoyable one.
Not a single one of the characters is dull. Cuba Gooding, Jr.
shines in even as small a part as Simon's art dealer. The outright offensiveness
of Melvin is anything but typical in an era of stifling political
correctness, making "As Good As It Gets" a truly original and very
enjoyable movie. In a year of occasionally dull and often predictable
movie-making, this film is nothing short of a gift.